Do you remember Martha Stewart going to prison?
In 2004, the well-known businesswoman was convicted of conspiracy, obstruction of justice and making false statements to federal investigators concerning her sale of stock in ImClone Systems.
The Securities and Exchange Commission alleged that Stewart had received confidential information before selling her shares, allowing her to avoid approximately $45,673 in losses. Although she was not criminally convicted of insider trading, she was convicted of offenses related to the investigation and served five months in federal prison.
Think about that for a moment. Less than $50,000 in avoided losses led to an investigation that ultimately resulted in a prison sentence.
I was reminded of Martha Stewart’s case when I read a Bloomberg investigation published last week about suspicious trading activity immediately preceding an important announcement by President Donald Trump. The dollar amounts involved were considerably larger, and the government’s response raises questions that deserve our attention.
What Happened on March 23?
On March 23, President Trump announced that he was postponing threatened military strikes against Iranian power plants. The announcement had an immediate impact on financial markets. The prospect of reduced military tensions meant less risk of disruption to oil supplies, causing oil prices to fall while stock prices rose.
But something unusual happened just before the announcement.
According to Bloomberg reporters Charles Gorrivan, Lydia Beyoud and Nicola M. White, traders placed billions of dollars’ worth of contracts anticipating falling oil prices and rising stock prices approximately 15 minutes before Trump’s announcement appeared on Truth Social. Some traders appeared to have positioned themselves remarkably well for news that had not yet been made public.
Was it extraordinary luck? Was it the result of sophisticated market analysis? Or did someone have advance knowledge of what the president was about to announce?
We don’t know. And that is precisely why the trading activity deserved examination.
The Government’s Financial Watchdog
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or CFTC, is the federal agency responsible for regulating futures, options and certain other derivatives markets. Its responsibilities include protecting market participants against fraud, manipulation and abusive trading practices.
Think of it as one of the government’s financial watchdogs. When unusual trading activity occurs, the CFTC has specialists who examine trading patterns, identify potentially suspicious transactions and determine whether additional investigation may be warranted.
According to Bloomberg, career analysts at the agency reviewed the March 23 trading activity and prepared a referral to its Division of Enforcement. That referral was not a finding of wrongdoing. It was a recommendation that the agency examine whether the trading activity warranted further investigation. What happened next caught my attention.
Bloomberg reported that Mel Gunewardena, a senior adviser to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, instructed staff to withdraw the referral. In other words, the agency’s analysts had identified transactions they believed deserved additional scrutiny, but senior leadership intervened in the referral process.
A CFTC official offered an explanation, telling Bloomberg that the original review was too narrowly focused on U.S. trading and that the agency wanted a broader international examination. The official also said that the Enforcement Division was continuing to examine trading activity surrounding the March 23 announcement.
That explanation is important. Withdrawing a referral does not necessarily mean that an investigation has been stopped. Nevertheless, the intervention raises legitimate questions about how investigative decisions are made and whether career analysts can perform their responsibilities independently.
Remember Martha Stewart?
This is where the Martha Stewart case becomes relevant.
In December 2001, Stewart sold approximately 3,900 shares of ImClone Systems stock after receiving information that the company’s chief executive and his daughter were selling their shares. The SEC alleged that the transaction allowed her to avoid losses of approximately $45,673.
Federal investigators examined the circumstances surrounding the sale. Stewart subsequently provided explanations that a jury determined were false, resulting in her criminal convictions.
The case illustrates an important principle: financial regulators must be able to investigate suspicious transactions, follow the evidence and determine whether laws have been violated. That doesn’t mean every suspicious trade is illegal. Nor does it mean that everyone investigated is guilty. It means the investigative process matters.
The Martha Stewart case involved less than $50,000 in avoided losses. The March 23 transactions involved billions of dollars in contracts, although we don’t know the traders’ actual profits or whether any laws were broken.
These are different circumstances involving different financial markets and regulatory agencies. But the underlying principle is the same. When financial regulators identify suspicious transactions, shouldn’t they be allowed to determine whether wrongdoing occurred?
Why Independent Oversight Matters
During my years working in financial management, I came to appreciate the importance of internal controls, independent audits and accountability.
One of the fundamental principles of good financial management is that the people responsible for monitoring transactions must be able to report concerns without improper interference.
Imagine a company’s internal auditors discovering unusual transactions involving millions of dollars. They prepare a report recommending further investigation. Before the report reaches the appropriate oversight committee, someone in senior management instructs them to withdraw it. Would that prove fraud had occurred? Of course not.
But wouldn’t it raise serious questions about the company’s financial controls and the independence of its auditors? I believe most responsible executives and board members would want an explanation. The same principle should apply to our federal government. Regulatory agencies exist to enforce laws enacted by Congress, not to protect any administration from uncomfortable questions.
Bloomberg’s investigation also reported that the CFTC has experienced substantial staffing reductions and a sharp decline in enforcement actions during Trump’s second term. Fewer employees and fewer enforcement actions do not automatically mean that the agency is failing to do its job. Enforcement numbers can fluctuate for legitimate reasons.
However, when those changes occur alongside reports of intervention in the handling of potentially sensitive transactions, the public has reason to ask whether the agency has the independence and resources necessary to fulfill its responsibilities.
This Isn’t About Proving Someone Guilty
There is no publicly established evidence that President Trump participated in the trades, disclosed confidential information to traders or personally directed anyone at the CFTC to withdraw the referral. There is also no public finding that the traders engaged in illegal insider trading.
The Bloomberg investigation raises questions. It doesn’t answer all of them. We should be just as careful about making unsupported accusations of financial wrongdoing as we should be about accepting unsupported claims concerning voter fraud or political candidates. But that works both ways.
We shouldn’t accuse people of wrongdoing without evidence, and we shouldn’t discourage investigators from gathering evidence simply because the investigation might be politically inconvenient.
Who Is Watching the Watchdogs?
Our financial markets depend on confidence that everyone is playing by the same rules.
Millions of Americans have retirement savings invested in stocks, bonds and other financial instruments. They rely on the integrity of markets even if they never personally purchase an oil futures contract. If some traders have access to confidential government information that others don’t, and use it illegally to profit, ordinary investors are operating at a disadvantage. That is why independent regulatory oversight matters.
Martha Stewart’s case reminds us that even relatively small transactions can lead to serious consequences when investigators uncover violations of the law.
The March 23 trading activity raises a different question: whether regulators are being permitted to investigate suspicious transactions when the potential implications could be politically sensitive.
I don’t know whether anyone broke the law on March 23. Neither does the public, based on the evidence reported so far. But I believe the public deserves to know why the original referral was withdrawn, whether the promised broader investigation is proceeding, and whether the agency’s career investigators have the independence necessary to follow the evidence.
The issue isn’t whether the traders are guilty. It’s whether the people responsible for enforcing our financial laws are being allowed to find out. And that leads me to one final question.
If the government’s financial watchdogs identify suspicious activity, who is making sure they can investigate it without improper interference?
Quote of the Day
“Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.”
— Louis D. Brandeis, Other People’s Money and How the Bankers Use It (1914)
Brandeis understood something that remains true more than a century later. Transparency and public scrutiny are essential to holding powerful institutions accountable.
Orchid of the Day
Bloomberg reporters Charles Gorrivan, Lydia Beyoud and Nicola M. White for breaking the story about the trades that occurred on March 23, 2026.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to government officials who fail to provide clear explanations when they intervene in the work of independent investigators.
Senior officials have legitimate authority to oversee regulatory agencies and establish enforcement priorities. However, when an investigative referral is withdrawn, transparency about the reasons and the status of any continuing investigation is essential to maintaining public confidence.
Question of the Day
Should federal financial regulators be required to notify Congress when senior political appointees intervene in or withdraw referrals involving potentially suspicious financial transactions?
Would such a requirement strengthen accountability, or could it interfere with legitimate management of investigations?
I’d be interested in your thoughts.
Lyrics of the Day
Friday’s answer: “There’s a lady who’s sure all that glitters is gold.” from Stairway to Heaven by Led Zepplin.
Today’s lyric:
“Money, it’s a gas.”
Name the song and the artist, and put your answer in the comment section below.
Answer in Wednesday’s blog.
Video of the Day: If you are a Ted Lasso fan, you will love this.

