Ever since President Trump began imposing tariffs on imported goods last year, something has bothered me. We were repeatedly told that foreign countries would pay the tariffs. However, that was not how the system worked.
American companies importing products paid the tariffs to the federal government. Those companies could absorb the expense, pass it along to customers through higher prices, or do some combination of the two.
Economic research suggests that American consumers ultimately bore a significant share of the cost through higher prices.
Then something happened that made the situation even more interesting.
On February 20, 2026, the United States Supreme Court ruled that President Trump had exceeded his authority by imposing tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. The decision invalidated the tariffs, leaving the federal government responsible for refunding billions of dollars collected from American importers. Refunds are estimated to total approximately $170 billion.
That raises a question that has continued to bother me.
If companies raised their prices to recover the cost of tariffs, and the government is now refunding those tariffs, shouldn’t the customers who paid the higher prices receive some of that money?
Apparently, that is not necessarily happening.
Some Companies Are Getting a Windfall
A November 16 investigation by ProPublica examined thousands of corporate financial disclosures to determine what companies were doing with their tariff refunds. Their findings were troubling.
Stanley Black & Decker, the manufacturer of tools and other products, repeatedly raised prices after the tariffs were imposed. Company executives explained that those increases were necessary to offset tariff expenses.
Now the company is receiving at least $298 million in tariff refunds. According to ProPublica, the financial benefit is contributing to incentive compensation, including bonuses.
TJX, the parent company of TJ Maxx and Marshalls, received $331 million in refunds. It subsequently recorded $112 million in additional expenses for incentive compensation and discretionary bonuses for eligible employees.
ProPublica identified at least nine publicly traded companies that disclosed using some of their tariff refunds for bonuses or incentive compensation.
I question whether money returned because a government tax was declared unlawful should remain with the company passed the original cost onto its customers through higher prices.
Let’s Keep the Math Simple
Suppose a company imports a product and pays a $20 tariff.
To recover that expense, it increases the retail price by $20. The customer buys the product and effectively pays the tariff through the higher price.
Months later, the Supreme Court rules that the tariff was unlawful, and the government refunds the company its $20.
In this simplified example, the company has recovered the tariff expense twice: once from its customer and once from the government.
The customer receives nothing.
That is a simplified example. In the real world, companies may absorb some of the tariff expense, pass along only part of it, or incur other costs that a refund does not cover.
Nevertheless, the example illustrates the problem.
The company that wrote the check to the government is not necessarily the one that ultimately bore the economic cost.
Who Should Get the Money?
A Wisconsin consumer has filed a lawsuit against Stanley Black & Decker, arguing that the company should not be permitted to recover tariff costs from customers and then receive the same money again from the government. Whether that lawsuit will succeed remains uncertain.
There are two separate questions here.
The first is whether companies that paid those tariffs have legitimate claims to recover them.
The second is whether companies that passed the costs along to customers have an ethical responsibility to share the financial benefit.
I believe they do.
I recognize that refunding individual consumers would be enormously complicated. Retailers cannot easily identify every customer who purchased an affected product or determine how much of its price reflected tariffs.
But there are alternatives.
Burlington Stores, the discount retailer, received approximately $55 million in tariff refunds. Rather than treating the money as a one-time increase in profits, its leadership has announced plans to use the benefit to provide more competitive prices for customers.
That doesn’t reimburse everyone who previously paid higher prices, but it demonstrates that businesses have choices.
I believe companies should disclose how much they received in refunds, how much of the tariff expense they passed along through higher prices, and how they intend to use the refunded money.
When a company raised prices specifically because of tariffs and subsequently receives those payments back, retaining the entire refund deserves scrutiny.
A Question of Fairness
To me, this is not a political issue. It is a question of fairness.
We should be able to recognize the distinction between the person who pays a tax to the government and the person who ultimately bears its expense. And we should question whether our laws adequately address that distinction.
If American consumers helped pay the tariffs through higher prices, shouldn’t they share in the refunds when those tariffs are returned?
************************************************************************************
A Follow-Up to Wednesday’s Measles Article
Wednesday’s article about the United States losing its measles elimination status generated some interesting responses.
Several readers questioned why I had not addressed the potential role of illegal immigration in the return of measles.
I appreciate the comments because they raise a legitimate question: Where did these infections originate, and how did measles become established in the United States again?
There is an important distinction that I believe deserves clarification.
Introducing a disease into a country is not the same as allowing that disease to spread continuously within the country.
When the United States achieved measles elimination status in 2000, it did not mean that no one would ever bring measles into the country again. For the next twenty-five years infected travelers continued to arrive from other countries. Those travelers were American citizens returning from abroad, international visitors, or immigrants, both legal and illegal.
Yet during those 25 years, the U.S. was able to prevent those introductions from developing into sustained transmission.
I asked CHAT GPT and Microsoft Co-Pilot and they found no credible evidence establishing that illegal immigration was the principal cause of the United States losing its measles elimination status.
That does not mean immigration and international travel are irrelevant to the introduction of infectious diseases. They are legitimate public-health considerations. However, immigration status does not automatically establish whether someone has been vaccinated or is carrying an infectious disease.
The CDC reports that the original source of the major 2025 Texas outbreak remains unknown. What we do know is that the disease spread extensively in communities with low vaccination coverage.
Some readers also questioned the responsibility of Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
As I noted Wednesday, declining childhood vaccination rates began before Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. assumed office. Assigning him responsibility for the measles resurgence would be inaccurate.
My original article was not intended to assign political blame. It was intended to ask why a disease we successfully controlled for more than 25 years has returned and we were not able to prevent its transmission during twelve consecutive months.
Regardless of how measles enters the country, maintaining high vaccination rates remains our strongest protection against sustained outbreaks.
I appreciate everyone who took the time to comment. I welcome differing opinions, but I believe our discussions are most productive when we distinguish established facts from assumptions.
We may disagree about immigration policy or public-health leadership. We should not have to disagree about the importance of reliable evidence that immunizations work.
Quote of the Day
“An investment in knowledge pays the best interest.”
— Benjamin Franklin
A reminder that understanding how something works is often the first step toward recognizing when it isn’t working fairly.
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to Burlington Stores, which has announced plans to use approximately $55 million in tariff refunds to provide better prices for its customers rather than treating the refunds as an immediate increase in profits.
Although this approach does not reimburse customers for every dollar they previously paid, it recognizes that consumers deserve to share in the financial benefit.
I hope other companies will consider following its example.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to corporations that passed tariff costs on to consumers and are now directing refund windfalls toward employee compensation programs or the company’s bottom line.
Question of the Day
When a company receives a refund for tariffs it previously passed along to customers through higher prices, should it be required to return some of that money to consumers, or should the company be free to decide how the refund is used?
Lyrics of the Day
Today’s lyrics come from a song about money and its influence on our lives.
“Money, money, money”
Can you name the song and the group that made it famous?
Answer to Wednesday’s Lyrics of the Day: “Lean on Me,” written and originally recorded by Bill Withers in 1972.
Video of the Day

