Today I have two subjects that caught my attention over the weekend. The first concerns President Trump’s claim that America is making a fortune from higher oil prices resulting from the war with Iran. The second involves Saturday night’s dramatic World Series ending, when a split-second decision by an umpire I know personally helped determine the outcome of the game.
One story involves the American economy and the other involves baseball. On the surface, they have little in common.
Yet both raise important questions about how we evaluate what we see and hear. In one case, the question is who benefits and who bears the costs. In the other, the question is who gets to make difficult judgments when the stakes are highest.
In both cases, the headline tells only part of the story.
****************************************************************************************************
When the President Says We’re Making a Fortune, Who Exactly Is “We”?
I regularly read Heather Cox Richardson’s Letters from an American. I appreciate her willingness to examine current events and place them in a broader historical context.
In her October 25 newsletter, Richardson discussed President Trump’s repeated claims that the American economy is booming. She focused particularly on comments he made Saturday at a rally in Georgia, where he described the financial benefits American oil producers are receiving because of disruptions to global energy supplies caused by the war with Iran.
At one point, Trump declared, “We’re making a freaking fortune.”
Richardson responded by asking a simple but important question: Who exactly is “we”?
That question immediately caught my attention because it goes to the heart of how we evaluate economic claims.
When oil prices rise, some Americans benefit while others pay more. Energy companies may earn larger profits, but families, farmers and businesses often face higher costs. Before deciding whether “we” are making a fortune, it seems fair to ask who is receiving the money and who is paying the bills.
What Do the Numbers Tell Us?
The United States is the world’s largest producer of crude oil, and American energy companies have benefited from higher global oil prices. When disruptions in the Persian Gulf reduce supplies, buyers naturally look elsewhere for energy, including American producers.
Higher prices can generate additional revenue, profits, investment, jobs and tax revenue. Those are legitimate economic benefits and help explain the president’s remarks.
But there is another side to the story.
Before the war with Iran began in February, the national average price of regular gasoline was approximately $2.98 per gallon. As of this morning, it was approximately $4.29. Diesel fuel has risen from about $3.76 to $6.35 per gallon.
That represents an increase of roughly 44% for gasoline and 69% for diesel.
For someone driving 15,000 miles annually in a vehicle averaging 25 miles per gallon, the increase in gasoline prices would mean approximately $786 in additional fuel costs over a year if current prices persisted.
The impact, however, extends far beyond what we spend at the pump.
Diesel fuel powers much of America’s trucking fleet, agricultural equipment and commercial transportation system. When diesel prices rise, the costs of moving goods and providing services rise as well. Some businesses absorb those costs, but many ultimately pass at least part of them on to consumers.
As a result, higher fuel prices can affect everything from groceries and home-delivery services to manufactured goods and agricultural production.
Is America Really Making a Fortune?
President Trump argues that the war has increased demand for American oil and gas, creating significant financial opportunities for American producers.
But when discussing the economic consequences, it is important to distinguish between gains that benefit particular industries and gains that benefit the nation as a whole.
There may be substantial profits for American oil companies, investors and energy-producing regions. At the same time, millions of households, farmers, transportation companies and manufacturers are paying more for fuel and countless fuel-dependent products.
That brings me back to Richardson’s original question.
When President Trump says “we” are making a fortune, shouldn’t Americans ask who is receiving the money and who is paying the bills?
***********************************************************************************************
One Swing, One Call, and a World Series Controversy
Saturday night’s World Series game between the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays ended in one of the toughest calls an umpire has to make. It was a call that was not reviewable by video replay. It was a call that James Hoye had to make in a split second. It was a call that was replayed over and over immediately following the end of the game by the Fox announcers and the Fox baseball analyst.
Milwaukee was leading 5-4 in the top of the ninth inning. There were two outs, the tying run was on third base, and Tampa Bay’s Yandy Díaz was batting against Brewer’s reliever Aaron Ashby. The count was three balls and two strikes. One more pitch could determine the outcome of the game.
Ashby threw a breaking ball that bounced in the dirt. Díaz started to swing but attempted to stop before completing the motion. Home plate umpire Jim Wolf initially ruled that the batter had not swung, but Milwaukee catcher William Contreras requested an appeal to first-base umpire James Hoye.
Hoye ruled that Díaz had attempted to hit the pitch. Strike three. Ball game. Milwaukee wins 5-4 and takes a two-games-to-none lead in the World Series.
Díaz had already started toward first base, believing he had drawn a walk. When he realized Hoye had called him out, he looked toward first base in disbelief, repeatedly shaking his head. He clearly believed he had stopped his swing in time.
For baseball fans, it was a controversial ending. For me it brought back plenty of memories.
This situation was one that I had to deal with many times in my career. It is a situation that I always covered in my pregame preparation with my partner. So many things happen in the blink of an eye.
What Does the Rulebook Actually Say?
Here’s something many baseball fans may not realize: Major League Baseball’s rulebook does not provide a specific definition of a checked swing.
There is no rule stating that a batter has swung if his wrists break, if the bat crosses home plate or if the barrel moves beyond a particular point.
Instead, the rulebook defines a strike, in part, as a pitch that the batter attempts to strike and misses. The umpire must determine whether the batter made an attempt to hit the pitch.
That sounds simple, but making the judgment in real time is anything but simple.
A batter may start his swing, recognize that the pitch is outside the strike zone and try to stop. His shoulders rotate, his wrists move and the bat travels forward. At some point, the umpire must decide whether those movements constitute an actual attempt to hit the ball.
When the home plate umpire rules that the batter did not swing, the catcher or manager can request an appeal to the appropriate base umpire. With a right-handed batter, that is generally the first-base umpire.
The base umpire then makes an independent judgment about whether the batter attempted to hit the pitch.
That is exactly what happened Saturday night.
Why This Was Such a Difficult Situation
Think about everything happening simultaneously. There are two outs, the tying run is at third base, the count is full, and the pitcher delivers a breaking ball that bounces in the dirt. The batter begins to swing and tries to stop. The catcher must handle the pitch, recognize the possible checked swing and decide whether to appeal.
Meanwhile, the plate umpire is judging the location of the pitch, observing the batter’s movement and maintaining awareness of the runner at third base.
If the batter did not swing, it was ball four and the inning would continue. If the batter attempted to strike the pitch, it was strike three, with the result also depending on the rules governing an uncaught third strike.
Now consider Hoye’s responsibility. He has only an instant to evaluate the batter’s movement and make his judgment. He cannot stop the game and request several replay angles or watch the play in slow motion before deciding. And he knows that his decision could end a World Series game.
I Know Something About James Hoye
As I mentioned in Friday’s Orchid of the Day, I know James Hoye through my years attending the Southeast Michigan Umpire Camp. Both Hoye and fellow World Series umpire Nic Lentz served as instructors at the camp, which I attended for many years.
I had the privilege of learning from both men and seeing firsthand the professionalism, preparation and dedication they brought to the craft of umpiring.
One of the lessons I learned was the importance of making a decision confidently and then moving on to the next play. An umpire’s responsibility is to apply the rules and make the best judgment possible based on what they see.
Saturday night, Hoye was asked one question: Did Díaz attempt to hit the pitch? His answer was a confident and decisive yes. See the Video of the Day.
Should Technology Make These Calls?
Major League Baseball has increasingly used technology to improve the accuracy of umpiring decisions. Replay review has become part of the game, and the automated ball-strike challenge system was introduced in the major leagues this season.
But checked-swing judgments are not subject to ordinary replay review.
MLB has experimented in the minor leagues with measuring how far the bat travels during an attempted swing, including a proposed 45-degree threshold.
Such a system could make checked-swing decisions more consistent, but it would also change the traditional standard from determining whether the batter attempted to hit the ball to measuring how far the bat moved.
I appreciate the benefits of technology, but I also recognize that baseball has always depended on human judgment. The challenge is determining which decisions should remain with umpires, and which can be improved through objective measurements.
Saturday night’s ending will undoubtedly contribute to that discussion.
Whether you agree or disagree with Hoye’s decision, I hope you’ll appreciate the skill, preparation and concentration required to make that call with an entire World Series game hanging in the balance.
Sometimes the most difficult part of umpiring isn’t knowing the rules. It’s having the judgment and confidence to apply them when everyone is watching.
**************************************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.” - William Bruce Cameron
I thought this was particularly appropriate for today’s discussion.
Economic statistics can tell us how much money an industry is making, but they don’t necessarily tell us how ordinary Americans are doing financially. And while technology can measure how far a baseball bat travels, that doesn’t automatically answer the traditional question of whether a batter attempted to hit the pitch.
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to Major League Baseball umpire Jim Wolf, who worked home plate during Saturday night’s World Series game between the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays.
As someone who has umpired baseball, I pay particular attention to the performance of the home plate umpire. Throughout Saturday’s game, I was impressed with Wolf’s work behind the plate. His calls were loud and decisive. He was communicating with the catchers, batters, and pitchers, which is an important part of the plate umpire’s job. He maintained control of the game and handled the pressure of a World Series assignment with professionalism. His calls were confirmed on 3 of the 5 challenges.
Most of all, Wolf’s love of the game showed as usual. There is a reason he is one of my favorite umpires.
Onion of the Day
University of Michigan offensive coordinator Jason Beck for his play calling during Michigan’s overtime loss to Indiana.
Question of the Day
Should Major League Baseball continue allowing umpires to make checked-swing judgments, or should technology establish a measurable standard for determining whether a batter swung?
I’d be interested in your thoughts.
Lyrics of the Day
Today’s lyric: “You don’t need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.”
Name the song and the artist. Put your answer in the comment section below. Answer in Wednesday’s blog.
Friday’s answer: “War, what is it good for?” comes from War, made famous by Edwin Starr in 1970. The song became one of the best-known antiwar recordings of the Vietnam era.
Video of the Day: Did Yandy Diaz swing? A breakdown


I think it is important to have umpires make subjective calls like was the batter attempting to hit a ball. Stick with the umpire on checked swing calls.
Dylan; Subterranean Homesick Blues.