For today’s Thoughts for the Day, I have two subjects that caught my attention this week. The first involves new evidence about noncitizens registering and voting in American elections. The second involves oil prices and why gasoline remains so expensive despite reports that more oil is leaving the Middle East than before the war with Iran began.
At first glance, these subjects have little in common. But both illustrate something I believe is increasingly important: We need to understand what the numbers actually tell us before drawing conclusions.
*******************************************************************************************************
Noncitizen Voting: What Does the Evidence Really Tell Us?
I’ve written several times about President Trump’s repeated claims that large numbers of noncitizens are voting in American elections, potentially changing the outcomes. I’ve questioned those claims because the evidence I’ve seen has never come close to supporting them.
Last week, I read a fascinating investigation published by The New York Times on October 15, titled “How Claims of Widespread Noncitizen Voting Fall Apart.” The Times examined government investigations, election records and criminal prosecutions dating back to 2020. What caught my attention was the enormous difference between the number of suspected illegal voters initially identified and the number of cases that ultimately resulted in criminal charges.
Consider Iowa. In 2024, state officials announced that they had identified 2,176 suspected noncitizens on their voter rolls. But after reviewing additional federal records, the number was reduced to 277. Eventually, 11 noncitizens were charged with illegally registering or voting in recent elections. According to the Times, only one person still faced active charges involving a vote in Iowa’s 2024 general election.
One potentially illegal vote among more than 1.6 million ballots cast is not going to impact the outcome of many elections.
The Times found similar patterns elsewhere. Initial allegations involving hundreds or thousands of potentially ineligible voters often became substantially smaller after additional investigation. In Florida, Pennsylvania and Texas, the newspaper identified 25, 10 and 11 people, respectively, charged with noncitizen voting in the 2024 general election. Those are real cases that deserve investigation. But even if every charge resulted in a conviction, the numbers would represent an extraordinarily small fraction of the votes cast in those states.
The Times also examined the Heritage Foundation’s database and reported that the Heritage Foundation’s database identified 71 criminal convictions nationwide involving noncitizen voting between 2000 and 2025.”
That doesn’t mean every instance of illegal voting was discovered. It does demonstrate how few documented convictions have emerged over a long period.
Then Came the California Arrests
Just as I was considering writing about the Times investigation, the Justice Department announced a new series of criminal charges on Monday. Federal authorities charged 28 lawful permanent residents in California with offenses involving allegedly fraudulent voter registrations, illegal voting or false statements related to citizenship. According to the Justice Department, 21 of the 28 defendants allegedly cast ballots in elections in which they were ineligible to vote.
This is an important development, and I don’t believe it should be dismissed simply because the number is relatively small. Noncitizens are prohibited from voting in federal elections. If someone knowingly violates that law, there should be consequences. But we also need to distinguish between someone being charged with a crime and someone being convicted.
The 28 individuals are presumed innocent unless proven guilty. And the charges involve different conduct, including registration violations and alleged voting across multiple elections, not necessarily 28 illegal votes in one election. California has approximately 23 million registered voters. Even if all 28 defendants are ultimately convicted, those cases alone would not establish widespread voter fraud.
There is another interesting development in California. Federal officials have identified approximately 20,000 people who they believe may be noncitizens on the state’s voter rolls. However, California election officials reviewing the information have already raised questions about its accuracy, including records involving people who appear to have been born in the United States.
That brings us back to the lesson from Iowa. A list of suspected noncitizens is not the same as a list of confirmed noncitizens. And being improperly registered is not necessarily the same as actually casting an illegal ballot.
What Should We Conclude?
I believe two things can be true at the same time. First, noncitizen voting does occur. Election officials should work to prevent it, investigate suspected violations and enforce the law. Second, the evidence presented so far does not support claims that millions of noncitizens are voting or that noncitizen voting has determined the outcome of recent national elections.
There is also an important distinction between protecting the integrity of our elections and creating unnecessary barriers for eligible voters. We should be able to accomplish both objectives: prevent illegal votes and ensure that every eligible American can exercise the right to vote.
With the November 3 midterm elections approaching, I think we should demand more than alarming headlines. If public officials claim that thousands of people are voting illegally, they should be prepared to show us the evidence. And if subsequent investigations substantially reduce those numbers, the public deserves to hear that too.
*************************************************************************************************************
More Oil Is Flowing. So Why Isn’t Gasoline Getting Cheaper?
I read another fascinating article in Tuesday’s Wall Street Journal that initially left me scratching my head. The Journal reported that more oil is now being shipped out of the Middle East than before the war with Iran began on February 28.
According to shipping-data company Kpler, Middle Eastern oil flows averaged more than 24 million barrels per day during the week ending October 18. Before the war, the region was shipping approximately 23.3 million barrels per day. That represents an increase of at least 700,000 barrels per day. Yet the price of Brent crude oil remained around $108 per barrel on Tuesday.
If more oil reaches world markets, shouldn’t prices be falling? That was my first reaction. I’ve always understood that oil prices are largely determined by supply and demand, with futures markets reflecting what buyers and sellers believe oil will be worth in the future. After reading the Journal’s investigation, I realized there must be something that I am not understanding. I asked Chat GPT to help me understand.
Getting Oil to Market Is Much More Expensive
The first thing to understand is that while total Middle Eastern oil shipments have exceeded prewar levels, shipments through the Strait of Hormuz itself remain at only about 82% of their prewar volume. The difference is being made up partly through pipelines in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates that bypass the strait.
Oil companies and shipping operators have also developed new methods of transporting oil through the dangerous waters near Iran. But those methods are extraordinarily expensive. The Journal reports that approximately 30 attacks on ships have occurred during October alone. Tanker operators face the risk of missiles, drones and attacks from small boats.
Insurance premiums have increased dramatically. Shipowners are demanding higher payments, and crew members are receiving substantial bonuses for making dangerous voyages. According to the Journal, freight costs for a supertanker carrying Persian Gulf crude to China recently approached $37 per barrel.
That is an extraordinary transportation expense. Even when the same amount of oil reaches its destination, the total cost of delivering it may be considerably higher than before the war. Those additional expenses ultimately must be absorbed somewhere in the supply chain, including the local gas pump.
Oil Prices Reflect What Might Happen Tomorrow
The second issue involves expectations about future supplies. Oil is traded in a worldwide market, and futures prices reflect what buyers and sellers expect regarding future supply, demand and risk.
Today, oil shipments are recovering, but the fighting continues. What happens if Iran intensifies its attacks? What happens if a major tanker is disabled or the alternative transportation routes are disrupted? What happens if American military protection is reduced? Traders must consider those possibilities when determining what they are willing to pay.
The Journal also reports that global oil inventories have become thin, leaving less protection against another disruption. When inventories are low, even a relatively small interruption can cause significant price increases. So, while the world may be receiving more oil today, buyers remain concerned about whether those supplies will continue tomorrow.
What About Gasoline Prices?
There is another factor that I hadn’t fully appreciated. Crude oil and gasoline are not the same products. Refineries must process crude oil into gasoline, diesel and other petroleum products. Those products then must be transported to consumers.
And while crude shipments from the Middle East have recovered, refined petroleum-product exports have not. According to the Journal, Middle Eastern exports of refined products were approximately 1.9 million barrels per day in September, compared with 4.7 million before the war. That is a substantial shortfall.
It means that even when more crude oil is available, the supply of gasoline, diesel and other finished products can remain constrained. Gasoline prices also reflect refining costs, distribution expenses, taxes and local market conditions. Consequently, an improvement in crude oil shipments doesn’t necessarily produce an immediate or equivalent reduction in gasoline prices.
What Does This Mean for Us?
The consequences extend well beyond what we pay at the gas pump. Higher energy costs affect trucking, farming, manufacturing, construction and air travel. Businesses eventually pass many of those additional costs along to their customers. For families and retirees trying to manage household budgets, higher energy prices can make everything more expensive.
The encouraging news is that the world’s oil transportation system has demonstrated remarkable resilience. Despite the attacks, oil is still getting through. The discouraging news is that getting through is extraordinarily expensive, and no one knows how long the current arrangements can be sustained.
I began with the assumption that more oil reaching the market should mean lower prices. That assumption isn’t entirely wrong. Increased supply generally puts downward pressure on prices. But the Journal’s reporting helped me understand why that relationship isn’t always immediate or straightforward.
The question isn’t simply how much oil is flowing today. It’s how much it costs to deliver that oil and whether the world can count on those supplies tomorrow.
************************************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“Facts are stubborn things.” — John Adams
I can’t think of a more appropriate reminder for today’s two subjects. Whether we’re discussing election fraud or oil prices, the facts should guide our conclusions, even when they challenge what we initially believed.
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to the Detroit Pistons, who opened the 2026–27 NBA season Tuesday with an impressive 121–113 victory over the Boston Celtics.
What made the victory particularly enjoyable was the way the Pistons earned it. Detroit trailed by 22 points in the second half before mounting a remarkable comeback. Cade Cunningham and Jalen Duren each scored 22 points, Duncan Robinson added 21, and Javonte Green contributed 19 points after not playing in the first half.
The Pistons demonstrated the determination and resilience that Detroit sports fans love to see. One game doesn’t make a season, but defeating Boston after overcoming a 22-point deficit is certainly a wonderful way to begin. Congratulations to the Pistons. Let’s hope this is a preview of another exciting season of Detroit basketball.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to public officials who announce alarming numbers about suspected election fraud without clearly distinguishing allegations from verified findings.
Election security is too important to become a competition over who can produce the largest headline. When investigators uncover actual violations, they should prosecute them. But when thousands of suspected cases turn into a handful of verified ones, public officials have a responsibility to explain the difference. Americans deserve accurate information about the integrity of their elections, not inflated numbers that unnecessarily undermine public confidence.
Question of the Day
Should Congress establish a uniform national system for verifying citizenship when people register to vote in federal elections?
If so, how should that system be designed to prevent noncitizen voting without creating unnecessary obstacles for eligible American citizens? I’d be interested in hearing your thoughts.
Lyrics of the Day
Monday’s answer: “Money, it’s a gas” comes from Money by Pink Floyd, released on their landmark 1973 album The Dark Side of the Moon.
Today’s lyric: “You may say I’m a dreamer”
Name the song and the artist, and put your answer in the comment section below. Answer in Friday’s blog.
Video of the Day: Led Zeppelin Tribute - Foo Fighters, Kid Rock, Lenny Kravitz - 2012 Kennedy Center Honors. Please note David Grohl, who is normally the front man for the Foo Fighters, is playing the drums while their normal drummer, the late Taylor Hawkins, is the front man during the first song on the video.
Grohl, who is known as “Mr. Nice Guy”, is one of the most talented “Rockers” in history. He has been enshrined in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame twice. As the drummer for Nirvana, and as the founder and lead guitar for the Foo Fighters.


Imagine John Lennon