Maybe I am old school. Having raised two children, watched four grandchildren grow up, spent more than 50 years officiating baseball and basketball, and been married to a schoolteacher for more than five decades, I have developed some opinions about how we prepare children for adulthood. I recognize that parenting has never been easy, that every generation faces different challenges, and that most parents genuinely want what is best for their children. Nevertheless, I sometimes wonder whether our efforts to protect children from disappointment are making it more difficult for them to develop the independence, responsibility, and resilience they will need as adults.
My thoughts were prompted by an article in the November 11 edition of The Wall Street Journal, titled “Your Kid Got a Bad Report Card? Time to Sue!” The article describes several situations in which parents challenged teachers and school administrators over grades, disciplinary matters, and comments on report cards. In one case, a California mother filed a lawsuit after a third-grade teacher indicated on her son’s report card that he needed to improve his ability to cooperate with classmates and respond appropriately when frustrated. The mother disputed the teacher’s observations and, after failing to convince the school district to change them, took the matter to court.
Think about that for a moment. A third-grade teacher identifies an area where an eight- or nine-year-old child could improve his behavior, and the disagreement eventually ends up in court. Wouldn’t it have been more beneficial for the parents to sit down with their son, discuss what happened, and help him understand how he might handle a similar situation differently in the future?
The article also cited a 2024 Education Week survey in which four out of ten teachers reported experiencing pressure from parents to change grades. Another example involved a Tennessee teacher who resigned after a dispute over how administrators handled a student’s incomplete assignment. The teacher believed the administration had undermined her professional judgment to satisfy an unhappy parent. Whatever the merits of the individual disagreement, the situation raises a broader question about the challenges teachers face when parents and administrators disagree over student accountability.
What Happened to Supporting the Teacher?
Leah taught school for 40 years, and over the course of her career we had countless conversations about the challenges she encountered in the classroom. Based on my recollection of those conversations, parents became increasingly willing to challenge teachers and defend their children when disciplinary problems arose.
I grew up in an environment where, if my teacher called home because I misbehaved, I had some explaining to do and some punishment to face. My parents assumed my teacher was justified in raising the issue. They trusted that my teacher had my best interests in mind and was working in partnership with them to help me develop appropriate behavior, respect for others, and an understanding that actions have consequences.
Somewhere along the way, I believe that relationship has changed. In too many situations, the first reaction of a parent seems to be questioning the teacher rather than asking the child what happened. I recognize that there are excellent reasons for parents to challenge a teacher when a child has been treated unfairly. Teachers, like parents, make mistakes. My concern is with the assumption that a child must be right simply because he or she is our child.
What message are we sending when we automatically defend our children against criticism? Are we teaching them to accept responsibility for their behavior, or are we teaching them that someone else will always be available to defend their mistakes?
The Same Problem Exists in Youth Sports
I have observed a similar situation during my more than 50 years as a sports official. Anyone who has spent much time around youth or high school athletics knows that playing time can become a source of considerable disagreement between parents and coaches.
Every parent enjoys watching a son or daughter participate in sports, and it is understandable that parents want their children to have opportunities to play. However, coaches have responsibilities that extend beyond satisfying the expectations of individual parents. They must consider the needs of the team, the abilities of the players, their effort in practice, and numerous other factors when deciding who plays and how much.
Over the years, I have seen parents become extremely upset when their children did not receive the playing time they believed they deserved. Some confront coaches directly, while others take their complaints to athletic directors or school administrators to have those decisions changed.
Perhaps the more valuable conversation would involve asking the child what he or she could do to improve. Could the child practice harder, develop additional skills, demonstrate a better attitude, or ask the coach what is necessary to earn more playing time?
Those are lessons that extend far beyond the basketball court or baseball field.
Has the College Transfer Portal Made It Easier to Walk Away?
We are now seeing another dimension of this issue in college athletics, particularly with the growth of the transfer portal.
I recognize that the transfer portal has provided college athletes with opportunities they previously did not enjoy. Coaches frequently change schools, and athletes should have reasonable freedom to make decisions about their education and athletic careers. There are many legitimate reasons for transferring, including academic opportunities, coaching changes, family circumstances, and the desire to compete at a different level. However, I also wonder whether the ease of transferring has contributed to a culture in which some athletes are encouraged to leave whenever circumstances become difficult.
If a young athlete is not receiving the playing time he or she expected, is the best response always to look for another school? Would there be greater long-term value by staying, competing for a position, working to improve, and learning how to handle disappointment? My concern is whether we are losing sight of the value of perseverance and learning to overcome adversity.
What Happens When These Children Become Adults?
What happens when a child whose parents repeatedly challenged teachers enters college and encounters a professor who refuses to change a disappointing grade? What happens when an athlete whose parents regularly complained about playing time enters the workforce and discovers that promotions and opportunities are not always distributed according to personal expectations? What happens when a supervisor criticizes the quality of an employee’s work, an employer expects an assignment to be completed on time, or a coworker receives a promotion that someone else believes he or she deserved?
Life is filled with disappointment, criticism, competition, and circumstances that do not always turn out the way we would like. Learning how to deal with those situations is an essential part of becoming a responsible adult.
I spent much of my professional career in health care management, where I worked with people who had different abilities, personalities, expectations, and approaches to their responsibilities. One of the most important characteristics of successful employees and leaders was their willingness to accept constructive criticism, take responsibility for mistakes, and work to improve their performance.
Those characteristics do not suddenly appear when someone turns 18 or graduates from college. They develop over time through experiences that teach young people how to handle situations when things do not go their way.
I wonder whether some well-intentioned parents are inadvertently making that development more difficult.
Supporting Our Children Is Not the Same as Protecting Them from Every Consequence
Children need adults who will listen, provide guidance, protect them from genuine harm, and advocate for them when circumstances warrant it. However, there is a significant difference between helping a child resolve a problem and taking over the problem entirely.
When a child receives a disappointing grade, perhaps the first question should be, “What happened, and what can you do differently next time?” When a child is disciplined at school, perhaps we should begin by listening to the explanation and helping the child understand the expectations involved. When a young athlete is disappointed about playing time, perhaps we should encourage a conversation with the coach about what the athlete needs to improve.
Those approaches do not guarantee that the child will get the grade, playing time, or outcome he or she wants. They do something far more important. They help the child develop the confidence and skills needed to handle future challenges independently.
I keep returning to the mother who took a school district to court over comments on her third-grade son’s report card. I wonder what the child will remember about the experience years from now. Will he remember learning how to cooperate more effectively with classmates and respond appropriately when frustrated? Or will he remember that when a teacher criticized his behavior, his mother hired an attorney?
Our responsibility as parents is not to remove every obstacle our children encounter. It is to prepare them to overcome those obstacles themselves.
**************************************************************************
A Special Thought on Veterans Day
Today is Veterans Day, an opportunity to recognize and thank the millions of men and women who have served in the United States Armed Forces. Regardless of our political beliefs or opinions about the military conflicts in which our country has participated, we owe a debt of gratitude to those who have answered the call to serve. Their willingness to sacrifice personal comfort, time with their families, and, in some cases, their physical and emotional well-being deserves our respect and appreciation.
As we recognize our veterans, I believe we should also remember that thanking them for their service is only part of our responsibility. We must make certain they receive the health care, mental health services, disability benefits, and other support they have earned. We should also remember the families who have shared in their sacrifices. Our appreciation for veterans should be demonstrated not only by what we say on November 11, but also by how we treat them throughout the year.
*****************************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“Prepare the child for the road, not the road for the child.”
— A commonly cited parenting proverb
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to the Michigan State Spartans men’s basketball team for their win on Tuesday against the Duke Blue Devils. MSU out hustled and out muscled Duke throughout the game. MSU showed that they are a top contender for a national championship.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to parents who automatically assume their children are right and attempt to overturn every disappointing grade, disciplinary decision, or coaching decision without first considering what their children might learn from the experience.
Question of the Day
Parents and grandparents: When your child receives a disappointing grade, is disciplined at school, or doesn’t receive the playing time he or she expected, should your first response be to challenge the adult responsible or to ask your child what happened and what could be done differently?
Lyrics of the Day:
We placed our boots before the dawn. Packed our lives and moved along. Left home waiting by the phone for places we might not come home from.
If you know the answer use the comment section of the blog to let me know your answer.
Answer to Monday’s lyrics of the day: The Michigan State University Fight Song
Video of the Day:


Great blog today . Agree with you on education and our Veterans.
Definitely agree with your comments on parents protecting their children from every disappointment.
My son is a college professor and receives emails from parents about student grades, etc…🤦🏼♀️
One parenting example of my own : my son wrongly got a detention (really) and I told him to just serve it for all the stuff he got away with 😝