As a kid, football was an important part of my life. I played tackle football until my senior year in high school, when asthma prevented me from continuing. I loved the game and the individual and team challenges it presented. I loved the feeling after a game of knowing I had left everything on the field, even though my body ached.
I was fortunate that I never suffered a serious football injury that has affected my adult life. Unfortunately, that has not been true for everyone who has played the game.
This past weekend provided a particularly sobering reminder of football’s physical risks.
During Sunday’s Detroit Lions game against the Minnesota Vikings, linebacker Jack Campbell suffered a neck injury while making a tackle. He was immobilized, taken from the field on a cart, and transported to a hospital for further evaluation. The Lions also lost several other players to injuries, including Brian Branch and DJ Wonnum, who were evaluated for concussions after colliding with each other. Other players left the game with injuries involving their necks, ankles, hips, and hamstrings.
These injuries are not evidence that any of these players will develop CTE. They are, however, reminders of the violent collisions that are part of football and the risks players accept every time they take the field. Most injuries heal. What concerns researchers today is the possibility that some of the effects of repeated head impacts may not become fully apparent until years or even decades later.
The second reminder came from a recent New York Times article discussing chronic traumatic encephalopathy, commonly known as CTE, and new research estimating how widespread the disease may be among deceased former NFL players.
As I thought about the article and conversations with two longtime friends who played college sports, one comment kept coming back to me. A former Big Ten quarterback told me, “I kind of wish my coaches in those days would have allowed and encouraged me to just go out of bounds instead.”
The more I thought about that statement, the more convinced I became that it deserved a broader audience.
Together, these stories prompted me to write the following open letter to parents, future parents, and grandparents.
I hope you will share it with anyone who is considering allowing a child to participate in a sport where repeated head impacts are a recognized risk. Parents have responsibilities that extend far beyond cheering from the sidelines. They also have a responsibility to understand the risks, ask questions, and insist that coaches and athletic organizations take reasonable precautions to protect their children.
Dear Parents and Future Parents,
If your son or daughter came home from school and announced they wanted to play football, hockey, soccer, or another sport where collisions and head injuries are possible, how would you respond? Would you encourage them to participate because of the many benefits of organized athletics? Would you worry about the possibility of an injury? Or would you simply assume that the coaches, schools, and organizations responsible for the sport have taken every reasonable precaution to protect your child?
I have spent more than 50 years involved in athletics, including decades officiating baseball and basketball. I believe strongly in the benefits of sports. They teach teamwork, discipline, perseverance, leadership, respect for others, and how to deal with both success and failure. Some of my most enduring friendships and memories have come from athletics.
I would never discourage parents from introducing their children to organized sports. But I do believe parents have an obligation to reconsider some long-held assumptions when new information suggests that participation in certain sports may carry risks that previous generations did not fully appreciate.
A recent New York Times article about CTE caused me to think about what parents should know before allowing their children to participate in sports where repeated blows to the head can be part of the game. The research is troubling enough by itself. But after sharing the article with two longtime friends who were college athletes in the 1970s, I became convinced that this is a conversation I wanted to have with parents and future parents everywhere.
My purpose in writing this letter is not to tell you which sports your children should play. It is to encourage you to ask questions, understand the potential risks, and make informed decisions that place your children’s long-term health ahead of short-term athletic success.
What I Believe Parents Should Know About the Latest Research
On October 28, researchers led by Boston University published a study in JAMA Network Open estimating that approximately 74.5% of former NFL players who died between 2008 and 2023 had evidence of CTE in their brains at death.
CTE is a degenerative brain disease associated with repeated impacts to the head. Researchers have identified it in former football players and participants in other activities involving repetitive head trauma. It can be associated with difficulties involving memory, thinking, behavior, and mood, although not everyone with CTE pathology experiences noticeable symptoms during life. At present, the disease can be definitively diagnosed only after death.
The researchers studied a population of 2,362 deceased former NFL players. Among 387 donated brains with a definitive CTE assessment, approximately 94% showed evidence of the disease. Recognizing that families of players who experienced neurological difficulties were more likely to donate their loved ones’ brains, researchers adjusted for that selection bias and arrived at the estimate of 74.5%.
I want to emphasize an important distinction for parents reading this letter. The study does not establish that three out of four living NFL players have CTE, nor does it tell us the percentage of college, high school, or youth football players who will eventually develop the disease. The findings are based on deceased professional players, not living athletes, and researchers acknowledge there are still important questions they cannot answer. Even so, the results are difficult to ignore.
For years, much of the public discussion about head injuries in sports has focused on concussions. But researchers have learned that repeated impacts to the head may be important even when an athlete never experiences an obvious concussion. A player can absorb hundreds of blows during practices and games without necessarily being diagnosed with a single concussion. That cumulative exposure is one of the reasons researchers are examining the long-term consequences of contact sports.
As a parent, I would want to know that before allowing my child to participate. I believe you deserve to know it, too.
What Two Old Friends Taught Me
After reading the article, I shared it with two close friends, George Mihaiu and Richard Kerns. Both were accomplished college athletes in the 1970s. George was the starting quarterback at Michigan State University, while Richard was an outstanding baseball player baseball at the University of South Alabama, where he played under the legendary Eddie Stanky.
Richard’s response was immediate. He was struck by the estimate that nearly three-quarters of the deceased former NFL players had CTE. He wondered about the countless blows football players absorb during their careers and whether the increased size, strength, and speed of today’s athletes might make some collisions even more dangerous.
But it was his next observation that caught my attention:
“It also makes you wonder, is it worth the risk to kids these days.”
Parents, I believe that is precisely the question you should be asking. Not whether your child has the talent to become a great athlete, not whether a particular sport might lead to a college scholarship, and not whether your community has a proud athletic tradition. The first question should be whether the benefits of participation justify the potential risks to your child’s long-term health.
George’s response was even more personal.
As a former Big Ten quarterback, George experienced firsthand the physical demands of college football. He recalled that several former teammates had died and that CTE had been identified in some of them. He specifically mentioned Eric “The Flea” Allen, a former teammate whose family, George said, described a difficult decline in his physical and mental condition during the final years of his life. George also expressed concern about other former players whose health has deteriorated, although those accounts should not be confused with confirmed CTE diagnoses.
George then reflected on how football was taught when he was young.
“In our day, most of us were coached and encouraged to put our heads and shoulders down to try to get that extra yard. Showed how ‘tough’ you were.”
He remembered the many times he had his bell rung during his playing days. At the time, that was often considered part of the game. Players were expected to shake it off, demonstrate their toughness, and get ready for the next play.
Then George said something that, to me, captured the entire issue:
“I kind of wish my coaches in those days would have allowed and encouraged me to just go out of bounds instead.”
I hope every parent reading this letter will think about that statement for a moment. A former Michigan State quarterback, looking back more than 50 years later, wonders whether avoiding a few unnecessary hits might have been the wiser choice.
George said he feels fortunate to be doing well today. He even managed to include a little humor about some of the questionable decisions he has made over the years. But beneath the humor was an unmistakable sense of concern for former teammates and friends who have not been so fortunate.
His observations reminded me that parents cannot evaluate the risks of football solely by looking at what happens during a game or a season. Some of the consequences researchers are studying may not become apparent until decades later, long after your children have played their final game.
Questions I Hope Every Parent Will Ask
I am not a physician or a neuroscientist, and I don’t pretend to have all the answers. But I believe you deserve enough reliable information to make thoughtful decisions about the risks you are willing to accept on behalf of your children.
One particularly revealing study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention compared head impacts among children ages 6 to 14 participating in tackle football and flag football. Researchers found that tackle football players experienced approximately 15 times as many head impacts and 23 times as many high-magnitude head impacts as children playing flag football.
That doesn’t mean every child who plays tackle football will suffer permanent brain damage. Nor does it mean flag football is entirely without risk. But it does demonstrate that parents can make choices that substantially reduce their children’s exposure to repeated head impacts while still allowing them to enjoy many of the benefits of the sport.
Football is not the only activity deserving your attention. Hockey, soccer, wrestling, lacrosse, and other sports can involve collisions, falls, or impacts to the head. The nature and frequency of those exposures differ considerably, and I would not suggest that the risks are identical. What I would encourage you to do is learn about the particular risks associated with the activities your children want to pursue.
I also want to acknowledge that sports have changed. There is greater awareness of concussions, improved medical protocols, rules intended to reduce dangerous contact, and increased emphasis on safer techniques. Those are positive developments. But protective equipment and better rules cannot eliminate every head impact, and a helmet designed to reduce certain injuries cannot guarantee protection against concussion or the potential effects of repeated brain movement.
Before enrolling your child in a contact sport, ask about concussion protocols, return-to-play policies, medical supervision, and practice rules. But after you’ve asked all those questions, there is one more question I think every parent should ask.
What happens when protecting my child’s health conflicts with your desire to win? I would pay very close attention to the answer.
What Are You Teaching Your Children About Toughness?
Those of us who grew up in the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s remember a different approach to athletic injuries. Players were often praised for playing through pain, refusing to leave a game, and demonstrating their toughness. Being told to shake it off or get back out there was not unusual.
I don’t believe most coaches who encouraged that behavior were deliberately placing their athletes in danger. Many were simply teaching the game as they had been taught. They did not have the scientific information available today, and the long-term effects of repeated head trauma were poorly understood.
But parents raising children today have access to information that previous generations did not.
And I believe that knowledge creates a responsibility to make different decisions when circumstances warrant them.
I hope you will never allow your child to believe that protecting their health is a sign of weakness. I also hope you will never feel pressured into allowing your child to participate in a particular sport simply because it is a family tradition, a source of community pride, or something your child is especially talented at doing.
There are many ways for children to develop confidence, discipline, leadership, friendships, and a love of competition. I encourage you to provide those experiences while continuing to examine how to make them as safe as reasonably possible.
I also recognize that parents will reach different conclusions. Some of you, after reviewing the available information, will be comfortable allowing your children to play tackle football. Others may prefer flag football or another sport. Still others may decide to delay participation in collision sports until their children are older.
I respect that these are family decisions. My hope is simply that you make them with a realistic understanding of the risks rather than an assumption that serious consequences happen only to someone else’s child.
What Can You Do to Reduce the Risks?
Parents, if you decide to allow your child to participate in tackle football or another contact sport, I encourage you to remember that protecting your child’s brain involves much more than purchasing a good helmet.
Researchers are increasingly interested in the cumulative effects of repeated head impacts, including blows that do not produce obvious concussion symptoms. That makes reducing unnecessary contact during practices, teaching safer playing techniques, and considering alternatives such as flag football particularly important for younger athletes.
The fewer unnecessary blows your child absorbs, the better.
I would also encourage you to pay close attention to how coaches respond when an athlete experiences a possible concussion. A child who is dizzy, confused, experiencing headaches, or showing other symptoms following a blow to the head should not be encouraged to shake it off and return to the game. The child should be removed from play and evaluated by an appropriate health care professional before returning to sports.
And don’t assume that purchasing the most expensive helmet will eliminate the danger. Helmets are important for protecting against certain injuries, but no helmet or accessory has been demonstrated to prevent CTE.
Finally, I would urge you to talk directly with your children about the importance of reporting injuries. Young athletes naturally want to play, support their teammates, and earn the approval of their coaches. They may be reluctant to admit that something is wrong, especially if they fear losing their position or disappointing someone.
Make sure your child understands that you will never be disappointed in them for reporting a possible head injury or choosing to leave a game. In fact, I believe that decision should be recognized as an example of maturity and good judgment, not weakness.
What I Hope You Will Remember
As I think about George’s comments, I keep returning to that extra yard.
In the excitement of a football game, gaining another yard can seem terribly important. It may produce a first down, keep a drive alive, or even contribute to winning a championship. But viewed from the perspective of a former quarterback looking back more than 50 years later, that same yard takes on a different meaning.
Was it worth lowering your head and absorbing another violent collision? Was it worth another occasion when your bell was rung? And if someone had explained the possible long-term consequences, might you have made a different decision?
I cannot go back 50 years and change what George, his teammates, or thousands of other athletes experienced. Nor do I believe it is fair to judge yesterday’s coaches solely by scientific knowledge that was not yet available to them.
But I can ask parents today to consider what that knowledge means for the decisions they make about their own children.
I am not suggesting that you eliminate football or discourage your children from enjoying the enormous benefits of organized athletics. I am asking you to take the emerging evidence seriously, insist that athletic organizations put player safety ahead of winning, and make sure you have the information necessary to make responsible choices.
And perhaps I can encourage you to reconsider what you teach your children about toughness. There is nothing weak about stepping out of bounds to avoid an unnecessary collision. There is nothing cowardly about reporting concussion symptoms or leaving a game when something doesn’t feel right. Sometimes the most courageous decision is recognizing that long-term health is more important than the next play.
To every parent and future parent, I offer this thought: Your child may remember a winning touchdown, a championship, or the excitement of playing alongside friends for the rest of their life. Your responsibility is to do everything reasonably possible to make sure they can enjoy those memories with their health intact.
A championship trophy eventually gathers dust. A winning touchdown becomes a story. The roar of the crowd fades.
Your child’s brain has to last a lifetime. No extra yard is worth a lifetime of regret.
******************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.” — Benjamin Franklin
Franklin was referring to fire prevention when he popularized this observation, but the principle applies equally well to protecting young athletes. Preventing unnecessary head impacts may be far more effective than trying to address their consequences decades later.
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to the scientists, medical researchers, physicians, athletic trainers, and coaches who are working to better understand brain injuries and make sports safer for future generations. Their work is helping families make decisions based on evidence rather than tradition alone.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to any coach, parent, school, or athletic organization that pressures a young athlete to ignore concussion symptoms or continue playing when their health may be at risk. Winning matters in sports, but protecting the people who play should always matter more.
Question of the Day
Knowing what we are learning about CTE and repeated head injuries, would you allow your child or grandchild to play tackle football? Why or why not?
A special invitation: If you played football or another contact sport, particularly during the years when concussions were often dismissed as simply getting your bell rung, I would welcome your reflections. What do you wish you had known then that you know today? Your experiences may help today’s parents make better-informed decisions for their children.
Lyrics of the Day
Today’s Lyrics: “Teach your children well”-If you know the answer submit in the comment section of this blog.
Answer to Friday’s Lyrics: “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” by The Rolling Stones.
Video of the Day: Former Detroit Lions medical staffer walks through Jack Campbell injury


A child's desire to participate in a sport (from my own experience) is founded at the playground. Pickup games helped some children realize quickly (by comparison to their friends) who was good and who were not so good.
Many of those that were not so good and chose not to continue in organized sports, succeeded in life by choosing the path of education. A sound education which inspired thinking and creativity. They became doctors, lawyers, accountants, etc... They all have benefitted by choosing the long term path for success and happiness.
I know of many friends that have realized their dreams 'without' the fan fare, the cheering crowds, or the constant desire to imitate professional players we watch everyday on TV! They did not hope blindly that they might succeed at a college or professional level at a sport that only 1 in a hundred thousand 'May' be chosen and pushed to do so. They were smart! And their parents were lucky that their children realized, for themselves, sports were not for them.
The best lessons I ever had were taught and learned by watching my friends (older, younger and some the same age) on the playground before organized sports. We taught each other. I was lucky to have those friends.
One thought came to mind when reading the article.... "All parents are parenting for the first time."
They are young, trying to grow a family, and faced with balancing financial decisions 'While' at the same time trying to provide and instill good decision making to their children as they grow into adults. They themselves need guidance to help guide.
Your article, which is extremely well written, delves deeply into the benefits and risk faced by every parent. I hope your message reaches many parents and helps guide them to guide their children to a long and prosperous life without growing ailments that accumulate with age.
Good article. Thanks Tom.
Teach Your Children - Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young