Leadership: Sometimes the Best Decision Is Letting Someone Else Make It
What does it mean when people routinely look to someone else to make decisions, they are perfectly capable of making themselves?
A few days ago, I posed that question to ChatGPT. It wasn’t prompted by anything particularly important. It was simply one of those everyday observations that makes you curious about human behavior. Why do some people seem comfortable accepting responsibility for making decisions while others prefer asking someone else what they should do? Is it a matter of confidence, experience, habit, courtesy, fear of making a mistake, or perhaps some combination of all those things?
What began as a simple conversation gradually evolved into a discussion about leadership, decision-making, and experiences from my years as a hospital administrator and CFO, board member, and as an umpire and referee. As ChatGPT asked questions and I answered them, I found myself reflecting on several management philosophies that guided me throughout much of my career. I don’t pretend these ideas are particularly original, nor would I claim I always followed them perfectly. Like most lessons worth learning, they were shaped by both successes and mistakes. Looking back, however, I think they served me reasonably well, and perhaps there are some useful lessons in them.
Provide Direction, Remove Obstacles, Trust People, and Follow Up
I always believed that one of management’s most important responsibilities was to create an environment in which people could succeed. To me, that meant making sure employees understood what we were trying to accomplish, had the resources necessary to do their jobs, and weren’t being slowed down by unnecessary barriers. Once those conditions were in place, I believed it was important to give people the freedom to exercise their own judgment and do their jobs without feeling the need to seek approval for every decision.
That never meant abandoning my responsibilities as a manager. On the contrary, it meant remaining available when people had questions, helping resolve problems when they arose, and following up to ensure that progress was being made. The difference was that I didn’t believe effective leadership required inserting myself into every decision. In fact, I often believed the opposite.
One thing I frequently told members of my staff was that I expected them to make decisions. If they were facing a genuinely difficult issue, I wanted them to come to me for advice. But if every decision, no matter how routine, had to move up the chain of command, then I wasn’t really developing people. I was training them to depend on me.
My general philosophy was that most employees would make good decisions most of the time. Of the decisions that didn’t work out exactly as expected, many could be corrected and most provided useful learning experiences. That seemed like a worthwhile trade-off if it helped people develop confidence and become more comfortable exercising independent judgment. I wanted people to know that I trusted them and that perfection wasn’t the expectation.
Over time, I also learned that there is often more than one reasonable way to solve a problem. Just because someone approached something differently than I would have didn’t mean they were wrong. Unless there was a compelling reason to intervene, I generally let their decision stand. Looking back, that’s probably one of the more valuable leadership lessons I learned. Having the authority to change someone’s decision doesn’t necessarily mean you should.
The Amount One Can Accomplish Is Unlimited If One Is Not Concerned About Who Gets the Credit
I’ve always liked that philosophy because it reminds us that accomplishing something worthwhile is usually far more important than receiving recognition for it.
Organizations succeed because of the combined efforts of many people. Unfortunately, it’s not unusual for individuals, departments, or even entire organizations to become overly focused on determining who deserves credit. When that happens, personal recognition can begin competing with the very objectives everyone is supposed to be pursuing.
I tried to approach things differently. When someone developed a good idea, solved a difficult problem, or helped achieve an important objective, I wanted that person to receive recognition for their accomplishment. I didn’t need my name attached to every success. As CFO, I remained accountable for the organization’s financial results, but those results were never the product of one individual. They reflected the efforts, judgment, and commitment of many people working together toward common goals.
I also learned that people respond positively when their contributions are acknowledged. Recognition builds confidence. It encourages initiative. It creates an environment where people are more willing to contribute ideas and accept responsibility. Perhaps most importantly, it reminds everyone that success is usually a shared achievement rather than an individual one.
Delegate Until They Puke
Yes, that really was my third philosophy.
It may sound a little crude, but it reflected something I came to believe strongly over the years. Most people possess more talent and capability than they realize, and sometimes the only way they discover that is by taking on responsibilities that initially make them uncomfortable.
During my years in management, there were many occasions when employees came into my office feeling overwhelmed. The first thing I tried to do was determine whether they truly had too much work or whether something else was contributing to the problem. Sometimes the workload genuinely was excessive and adjustments were necessary. More often, however, the underlying issue was concern about making mistakes.
People worried about making the wrong decision, disappointing their supervisor, or being held responsible for an outcome that wasn’t perfect. As we talked through those concerns, I would explain that I trusted their judgment and didn’t expect perfection. I wanted them to gather the facts, think through the alternatives, make the best decision they could, and learn from the experience. If mistakes occurred, we’d deal with them. That’s part of growth.
What I found especially rewarding was watching how many of those conversations ended. People who entered my office doubting themselves often left feeling more confident and capable. They began to realize they could handle responsibilities they had previously questioned. Not every conversation ended that way, of course, but enough did to reinforce my belief that one of a manager’s most important responsibilities is helping people develop confidence in their own abilities.
Of course, delegation has limits. Giving someone additional responsibility without providing training, resources, support, or guidance isn’t leadership. It’s simply transferring a burden. I called it “dumping”. That’s why this philosophy always had to be balanced with the first one. The goal wasn’t to overwhelm people. It was to challenge them, support them, and help them discover what they could accomplish.
Lessons From Sports Officiating
My years as an umpire and referee reinforced many of these same ideas, although in a very different setting.
As a sports official, you’re often required to make decisions instantly. There isn’t time to analyze every possible alternative or gather additional information. You observe the play, make the best judgment you can, communicate your decision, and move on. Sometimes you get it right and sometimes you don’t. Learning to accept that reality is part of becoming a good official.
One lesson that stayed with me involved working with fellow officials. There were occasions when I disagreed with a call made by one of my partners. Rather than openly challenging the call, I would quietly indicate that I had seen something different. My partner could then come over, listen to what I observed, and decide whether to maintain the original call or change it.
The important thing was that the decision remained his.
I believed that was important because the objective wasn’t to demonstrate who was right or wrong. The objective was to get the call right while still respecting the responsibility of the person who made it. The same principle often applies in management. Sometimes providing additional information or another perspective is more helpful than simply telling someone what to do. And sometimes the best thing a leader can do is allow another person to make a decision that might be different from the one the leader would have made.
What I’ve Come to Believe About Leadership
As I’ve reflected on these experiences over the years, I’ve come to believe that leadership is much less about having all the answers than many people assume. It’s about helping people understand where they’re headed, making sure they have what they need to succeed, and creating an environment where they’re comfortable exercising their own judgment. It also requires recognizing that mistakes are inevitable and that those mistakes can become learning opportunities rather than reasons to discourage initiative.
Perhaps the most important lesson I’ve learned is that confidence develops through responsibility. People don’t become confident decision-makers simply because they’re told they are capable. They become confident by making decisions, dealing with outcomes, learning from mistakes, and discovering that they are stronger and more capable than they originally believed.
Looking back, some of my most satisfying professional memories aren’t about financial results, major projects, or decisions I personally made. They’re about watching people grow, assume greater responsibility, gain confidence, and discover abilities they hadn’t fully recognized in themselves.
Maybe that’s one of the better ways to measure leadership, not by how many decisions we make, but by how well we’ve prepared others to make decisions without us.
***********************************************************************************
Why I Use ChatGPT to Help Write Thoughts for the Day
From time to time, readers ask how much of Thoughts for the Day is written by me and how much is produced with the assistance of ChatGPT. It’s a fair question, especially as artificial intelligence becomes an increasingly visible part of everyday life.
I’ve been writing Thoughts for the Day for more than five years, and the purpose of the publication hasn’t changed. I want to share information, explore interesting issues, encourage people to think critically, and occasionally offer my perspective on current events and public policy. What has changed are the tools available to help me accomplish those goals.
For years, a significant portion of my time was spent typing, editing, reorganizing paragraphs, correcting mistakes, and preparing material for publication. I enjoyed the learning, research, and writing process, but some of the mechanical work could be time-consuming.
Today, I use ChatGPT as a writing, editing, organizational, and research assistant. It helps me explore different perspectives, organize information more effectively, improve sentence structure, identify areas needing clarification, and prepare drafts. Most importantly, it allows me to spend less time wrestling with mechanics and more time learning, researching, and thinking about the subjects I’m covering.
To me, that distinction is important.
I don’t simply tell ChatGPT to write an article and then publish whatever appears on the screen. I choose the subject. I ask the questions. I review the information. I challenge conclusions. I request revisions. I decide what gets included and what gets omitted. Ultimately, I decide what is published.
In fact, the leadership article you just read is a good example of how the process works. It began with a simple question about why some people seem reluctant to make decisions. That conversation eventually led to memories from my years in management and sports officiating. The experiences were mine. The philosophies were mine. The lessons were mine. ChatGPT simply helped organize those thoughts into an article that I hope readers find informative and worthwhile.
I view artificial intelligence much the same way I view other technological developments that have changed how we work over the years. Typewriters made writing easier. Word processors transformed editing. The internet revolutionized research. Each innovation reduced some of the mechanical effort involved in producing information. Artificial intelligence is simply the next step in that progression.
That doesn’t mean there aren’t legitimate concerns. AI can make mistakes. It can present incorrect information with unwarranted confidence. It can sometimes produce polished writing that lacks personality or authentic human judgment.
Those concerns are real, and they deserve attention.
That’s why I believe the responsibility for accuracy, fairness, and integrity still rests with me. Important facts should still be verified. Sources should still be evaluated. Assumptions should still be questioned. If mistakes appear in something I publish, the responsibility for those mistakes remains mine.
I also want to preserve something else that has always been important to me: the personality of this publication. I’ve never intended Thoughts for the Day to read like a corporate report, a research paper, or a textbook. I’ve always preferred a conversational style that shares information while encouraging reflection and discussion. If artificial intelligence ever causes that personality to disappear, then it will no longer be helping me achieve my objective.
As I was thinking about all of this, I realized there was an interesting connection between my leadership philosophies and the way I use ChatGPT today.
One of my leadership principles was to provide direction, provide resources, remove obstacles, get out of the way, and follow up as necessary. In some respects, that’s also how I use artificial intelligence. I provide the directions. The technology helps perform certain tasks more efficiently. I review the results, exercise my judgment, and make whatever changes I believe are necessary.
Of course, there is one important difference. ChatGPT is a tool, not a person. It doesn’t possess judgment, life experience, or accountability. Responsibility for the final product remains entirely mine.
But the underlying principle is the same. We should make effective use of the resources available to us while remaining personally responsible for the results.
I don’t expect everyone to agree with my decision to use artificial intelligence, and I respect those who may prefer writing produced entirely without AI assistance. But I hope readers will continue to judge Thoughts for the Day the same way they always have: by the quality of the information, the strength of the ideas, the fairness of the analysis, and whether it provides something worthwhile to think about.
I’ve always believed that learning shouldn’t stop when we retire and that we should remain open to new ideas and technologies when they help us improve what we do. For me, ChatGPT has become one of those tools. It allows me to spend less time on the mechanics of writing and more time learning, thinking, and exploring subjects that interest me.
AI may help me write better, but it doesn’t relieve me of the responsibility to think for myself.
**********************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“The function of leadership is to produce more leaders, not more followers.”
— Ralph Nader
Orchid of the Day 🌺
In April Yaxel Lendeborg led the University of Michigan to the Men’s NCAA Basketball Championship. Last week Yaxel started his professional career with the Golden State Warriors. In one week Lendeborg is averaging 21.8 points, 9.3 rebounds, and 4.8 assists in just four games, with 31 points, 12 rebounds, six assists, and a block in a 134‑114 win over the Nuggets
Onion of the Day 🧅
To organizations that create needless layers of approval and bureaucracy.
When capable people need permission for every routine decision, innovation slows, frustration grows, and opportunities are often missed. Trust and accountability generally produce better results than excessive control.
Question of the Day
Think about someone who helped shape your career or your life. What did they do that gave you confidence in your own abilities?
Was it advice they offered? Additional responsibility they entrusted to you? Encouragement during a difficult time? Or simply their willingness to believe in you before you fully believed in yourself?
Lyrics of the Day 🎵
Yes, there were times I’m sure you knew when I bit off more than I could chew. But through it all, when there was doubt I ate it up and spit it out.
Name the song and the artist. Put your answer in the comment section below. Answer in Wednesday’s blog.
Monday’s lyrics: “Subterranean Homesick Blues” by Bob Dylan (1965)
Video of the Day: Calls of the Game: Detroit’s WALK OFF FIELD GOAL secures 20-17 win over Green Bay | Lions vs Packers


Yes Tom you did it your way!
TDB! I'm your biggest fan! I may just skim and not read all of your lengthy discussions especially about sports, etc. But I do read your opinions and appreciate the time you take to think and find supporting evidence of what you share.
I have noted when I am responding to an email that CHAT or whatever writes better than I might - how do it know what I think???
Somewhere out there I'm being monitored. Not sure I like it.
Hugs big guy on the bike.