The voters of Montana have sent a message. Will the new Congress listen?
I have followed American politics for more than 60 years. Candidates have always criticized their opponents, exaggerated their accomplishments, and occasionally stretched the truth to gain an advantage. Negative campaigning is nothing new. However, during the past decade, I believe the character of our political campaigns has deteriorated to levels that would have been difficult to imagine even 30 years ago.
Today, political advertising seems to be dominated by efforts to convince voters that the other candidate is dishonest, incompetent, dangerous, corrupt, or simply unfit for public office. Rather than telling us what they intend to accomplish, candidates and their supporters spend enormous amounts of money attempting to convince us that their opponents will destroy everything we value. In some cases, the accusations are legitimate and deserve public attention. In far too many others, the advertising relies on misleading statements, selective facts, distorted images, and emotional appeals designed to frighten or anger voters.
I am tired of it, and I suspect millions of other Americans are as well.
Last Tuesday, voters in Montana provided some evidence that Americans may be ready for a different approach to election politics.
A Message from Montana
On November 3, Montana voters overwhelmingly approved a ballot initiative designed to restrict the influence of corporations and other organizations in political campaigns. Approximately 65% voted in favor of the measure, while only 35% opposed it.
The initiative takes an unusual approach to a problem that has frustrated campaign finance reformers since the Supreme Court’s 2010 decision in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, which established that the government generally cannot prohibit corporations and unions from making independent expenditures to influence elections simply because the speakers are corporations or unions.
Rather than directly challenging that decision, Montana’s initiative attempts to use the state’s authority to establish the legal powers and privileges of corporations and other organizations. In effect, the measure says that organizations receiving certain legal privileges from the state should not be permitted to use those privileges to finance political campaigns.
A similar approach has been pursued in Hawaii.
Whether this strategy will survive constitutional scrutiny remains to be seen. In fact, opponents filed a federal lawsuit almost immediately after Montana voters approved the initiative, arguing that it violates First Amendment protections. The courts will ultimately determine whether Montana can enforce the law as written.
Nevertheless, I believe the significance of Montana’s vote extends well beyond the legal questions.
Nearly two-thirds of the voters supported an effort to reduce the influence of organizational money in elections.
That should get the attention of politicians in both parties.
Money Is Only Part of the Problem
The influence of money in politics is a serious concern, but I believe it is only part of a larger problem.
Consider the typical television advertisement during the final weeks of an election campaign. An unflattering photograph of a candidate appears, and a narrator tells us why electing that person would be a disaster. Often, the advertisement is financed by an organization whose name tells us almost nothing about the individuals or interests providing the money. By the time the election arrives, voters may know considerably more about what the candidates supposedly did wrong than about what either candidate intends to accomplish if elected.
I recognize that candidates must be able to challenge their opponents’ records, positions, and qualifications. If an elected official has engaged in corruption, abused public office, or supported policies that have harmed the public, voters deserve to know about it. Legitimate criticism is an essential part of democracy.
There is, however, a significant difference between holding an opponent accountable and deliberately attempting to mislead voters about that opponent. I believe we have lost sight of that distinction.
The result is a political environment in which anger, fear, and scare tactics have become powerful campaign tools. Candidates are rewarded for attacking their opponents, while thoughtful discussions of complicated public policy questions receive comparatively little attention. That is not healthy for our democracy.
An Opportunity for the New Congress
Last week, I wrote about the opportunity the newly elected Congress has to restore some of the constitutional responsibilities and ethical standards that I believe have been neglected in Washington.
I would like to add another priority to that list.
Congress should take the lead in establishing a voluntary code of conduct for federal election campaigns.
I would like to see Congress develop and publicly endorse a set of principles that candidates from both political parties would be encouraged to follow.
Those principles could include:
1. Tell voters what you intend to accomplish. Campaign advertising should place greater emphasis on candidates’ policy proposals, priorities, qualifications, and plans for governing.
2. Criticize honestly. Candidates should be free to challenge their opponents’ records and positions, but they should avoid false statements, fabricated accusations, and misleading representations of facts.
3. Take responsibility for your advertising. Candidates should publicly identify the advertising they authorize and promptly repudiate deceptive advertising conducted on their behalf, even when produced by organizations they do not legally control.
4. Disclose who is paying. Voters should have access to meaningful information about the individuals and organizations financing political advertising, consistent with constitutional protections and legitimate privacy concerns.
5. Treat political opponents with respect. Disagreement over public policy should not require personal insults, intimidation, or attacks on the character of individuals simply because they hold different political beliefs.
These would be voluntary standards, not government restrictions on political speech. Candidates who agreed to follow them could make that commitment publicly, allowing voters to evaluate their conduct throughout the campaign.
Congress could also consider legislation strengthening disclosure requirements, improving enforcement of existing campaign finance laws, and addressing the use of deliberately deceptive political advertising where constitutionally permissible.
I would also like to see respected organizations from across the political spectrum participate in developing these standards. The objective should be to establish expectations that reasonable people, regardless of their political affiliation, can support.
What About the Voters?
Even the best campaign guidelines will accomplish very little unless voters are willing to enforce them. That is where I believe the most important change must occur.
We, the voters, should stop rewarding candidates who conduct dishonest, misleading, and destructive campaigns.
If a candidate repeatedly misrepresents an opponent’s record, we should challenge those statements. And if a candidate refuses to follow reasonable standards of honesty and respect, voters should consider that behavior when deciding whether the individual deserves public office.
I am not suggesting that voters should automatically reject every candidate who runs a negative advertisement. There are times when serious criticism is entirely appropriate. I am suggesting that we judge candidates not only by their political positions but also by the character they demonstrate while seeking our votes.
Over the years, I have written frequently about the importance of honesty, integrity, character, and what I call our True North moral compass. I believe those values are just as important during an election campaign as they are after someone takes office.
The way candidates conduct their campaigns will most likely tell us how they will conduct themselves if elected. If they are willing to mislead voters to obtain public office, why should we expect them to become more honest once they have achieved that objective?
We Don’t Have to Accept Politics as Usual
The voters of Montana have demonstrated a willingness to challenge the influence of money in politics, even when doing so raises difficult legal questions. I believe that willingness reflects a broader frustration with the way our elections are financed and conducted. The newly elected Congress has an opportunity to respond to that frustration.
We should expect our political candidates to tell us why they deserve our votes, not simply why their opponents do not. And we, the voters, should be willing to reject candidates who believe that winning an election justifies abandoning the basic principles of honesty, integrity, dignity, and respect for others.
Montana’s voters have sent a message about the influence of money in politics. Perhaps it is time for the rest of us to send an equally strong message about the character of our political campaigns.
**********************************************************************************
There is a Reason Michigan Fired Their Offensive Coordinator
According to the Associated Press, the 2026 Michigan men’s football team is the 15th college football team in the last 15 seasons to hold every opponent to 21 points or fewer through its first nine games..
The combined records after nine games of the other 14 teams after 9 game in the season the performed the feat was 119-7 winning record. A 94,4% winning percentage.
After nine games Michigan has a 5-4 winning record. A 55.6% winning percentage.
See my Onion of the Day.
*************************************************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“Politics ought to be the part-time profession of every citizen who would protect the rights and privileges of free people.” — Dwight D. Eisenhower
Democracy works best when citizens remain actively involved in holding their elected officials accountable.
Orchid of the Day
Today’s Orchid goes to the voters of Montana, who demonstrated their willingness to address a serious problem.
Onion of the Day
Today’s Onion goes to the University of Michigan head football coach Kyle Whittingham. It is clear to me, that he had no idea of the importance of the UM/MSU rivalry, while MSU coach Pat Fitzgerald did. MSU was better prepared, played harder, and executed better. U of M got their butts handed to them in every facit of the game. In the second quarter I sent a text to by best friend George, a former MSU quarterback, that the game was an embarrassment. Little did I know it was only going to get worse in the second half.
Question of the Day
Would you support a voluntary code of conduct for political campaigns that encourages positive advertising, honest criticism, and greater transparency? More importantly, would a candidate’s refusal to follow those standards influence your vote?
Lyrics of the Day: Go right through for MSU. Watch the points keep growing.
If you know the answer provide your answer in the comments section of the blog.
Friday’s answer: A Hard Rains A-gonna Fall-by Bob Dylan
Video of the Day:

