Can Science Repair the Damage?
Researchers are exploring potential treatments for CTE. Their progress offers hope, but prevention remains our best protection.
On Monday, I wrote an open letter to parents and future parents about the potential long-term consequences of allowing their children to participate in football and other sports where repeated blows to the head are part of the game.
The central message of Monday’s article was that parents should understand the risks associated with repeated head impacts and make informed decisions about their children’s participation in contact sports. Today, I want to examine another aspect of this issue that offers some reason for optimism.
An October 28 article in The New York Times, written by Lynne Peeples, examined several research efforts that may eventually help answer that question. Although there is currently no established treatment that can cure or reverse CTE, researchers are exploring approaches that would have seemed highly unusual just a few years ago.
One of the more interesting developments involves the use of near-infrared light directed toward the brain through a specially designed headset. The approach, known as photobiomodulation, is based on the possibility that certain wavelengths of light may influence cellular activity, inflammation, and other biological processes associated with brain function.
Researchers at Brigham Young University and the University of Utah have been investigating whether this approach might help athletes who have experienced repeated head impacts. In a small, randomized study conducted in 2021, former football players received either active light treatment or a sham treatment several times each week. The final analysis involved 26 participants, and researchers reported encouraging differences in certain brain-imaging measures associated with inflammation and tissue integrity.
While the initial results are encouraging, changes observed in brain scans do not necessarily mean that the treatment can prevent or reverse CTE. Larger and more rigorous studies will be necessary before physicians can determine whether this approach offers genuine clinical benefits.
Researchers are also examining several other potential treatments, including medications intended to reduce inflammation, therapies involving the body’s immune system, and approaches that influence communication between the brain and other parts of the body.
Still others are investigating the relationship between the digestive system and the brain, including whether changes in the gut microbiome could influence neurological inflammation. Research involving stimulation of the vagus nerve, which connects the brain with several major organs, represents another possible avenue.
These approaches are at different stages of development, and none has been established as an effective treatment for CTE.
Currently, CTE can be diagnosed only after death, when brain tissue can be examined. That makes it extraordinarily difficult to identify people with the disease during their lifetimes, enroll them in clinical trials, and determine whether an experimental treatment is actually changing the course of the disease.
Researchers may be able to study symptoms, brain imaging, biological markers, and other indicators of neurological health. However, those measurements are not the same as demonstrating that CTE itself has been prevented or reversed.
I hope the investigations described in The New York Times eventually produce treatments that improve the lives of former athletes and others affected by repeated brain injuries. Those individuals and their families deserve every reasonable effort to understand the problems they face and develop effective treatments.
Parents should not interpret these early developments as evidence that the risks associated with repeated head impacts are becoming less important. Research is still a long way from knowing whether any of these approaches will prevent or treat CTE.
That brings me back to George Mihaiu and his reflections about gaining that extra yard. If coaches, parents, and athletes can reduce unnecessary impacts today, they may be able to prevent some of the problems that scientists are now struggling to treat.
**********************************************************************************************************
Governor-Elect Benson, I Haven’t Forgotten About Michigan
During the past two years, much of my writing about politics has focused on President Donald Trump and what I believe his actions have meant for our democracy, our Constitution, and the traditional standards of honesty, integrity, and character that we should expect from our elected officials.
I have not forgotten about Michigan.
Tuesday’s election produced significant changes in our state’s political leadership. Jocelyn Benson was elected governor, and Democrats won control of both chambers of the Michigan Legislature. Beginning in January, Democrats will have an opportunity to demonstrate what they can accomplish when they control the executive and legislative branches of state government.
I have been disappointed with several aspects of Governor Gretchen Whitmer’s administration, particularly when measured against two prominent commitments from her first campaign: fixing Michigan’s roads and making state government more transparent. I acknowledge Michigan has invested substantial amounts of money in road construction and repair during her administration. There have also been efforts to improve ethical standards and access to government information. Nevertheless, I do not believe the results have matched the expectations created by those campaign promises.
Jocelyn Benson served as Michigan’s secretary of state throughout much of Whitmer’s administration. She was not responsible for every decision made by the governor or the Legislature. However, she has been an important member of Michigan’s Democratic leadership, and she should understand why I am skeptical when I hear familiar promises the previously were not kept.
I have three priorities that I would like to see Governor-elect Benson and the newly elected Legislature address.
1. Make Michigan Government Truly Transparent
When Gretchen Whitmer first campaigned for governor in 2018, she promised to improve transparency in state government. Among other things, she indicated that she would voluntarily make the governor’s office subject to Michigan’s Freedom of Information Act. Eight years later, that promise remains unfulfilled.
Michigan has long been regarded as one of the least transparent states in the country.
One of the most troubling aspects of Michigan’s transparency laws is that the governor’s office and the Legislature are largely exempt from the Freedom of Information Act requirements that apply to many other public agencies.
Think about that for a moment. The people responsible for making some of the most important decisions affecting Michigan residents operate under different disclosure requirements from many of the government agencies they oversee.
During her campaign, Jocelyn Benson promised that she would voluntarily open the governor’s office to Freedom of Information Act requests, even if the Legislature had not yet enacted broader transparency reforms. Following Tuesday’s election, she repeated that commitment and said the policy would take effect on her first day in office. I applaud her for making the promise. Now I want to see her keep it.
I would also like to see the Legislature promptly pass legislation extending meaningful transparency requirements to the governor’s office and the legislative branch. I would especially like to see meaningful disclosure of the individuals and organizations financing political advertising and other efforts to influence elections.
If an individual or organization spends substantial amounts of money attempting to influence my vote, I believe I have a legitimate interest in knowing who is providing that money. As I wrote earlier this week about the federal government, public service is a public trust. That principle should apply just as strongly in Lansing as it does in Washington D.C.
2. Significantly Improve the Performance of our Children in our Public Schools
My second priority is improving the educational performance of Michigan’s children, particularly in elementary reading. Our state’s performance in this area is unacceptable.
Michigan has consistently struggled in national comparisons of student achievement. In several important measures, particularly elementary reading, our performance has been near the bottom of the country. According to the 2024 National Assessment of Educational Progress, only 25% of Michigan fourth graders reached the Proficient level in reading. Although that standard is more demanding than basic literacy, the results are deeply troubling. I consider that a failure of our collective responsibility to Michigan’s children.
If you can read, you can learn almost anything.
Reading is the foundation upon which virtually every other academic subject is built. A child who struggles to read will often struggle with mathematics, science, history, and the countless other subjects that require understanding written information.
The consequences extend well beyond the classroom. Reading ability affects employment opportunities, financial independence, access to information, and an individual’s ability to participate fully in society. I believe every child in Michigan deserves the opportunity to become a proficient reader, regardless of family income, neighborhood, race, or the school district in which the child happens to live.
That requires more than increasing education spending and hoping that better results will follow.
I would like to see Governor Benson and the Legislature establish a comprehensive, measurable plan for improving elementary reading achievement. That plan should include evidence-based instruction, effective teacher preparation, ongoing professional development, early identification of students who are struggling, and timely intervention before those children fall further behind. The plan should also establish ambitious but realistic improvement goals, publish progress reports, and hold the responsible institutions accountable for achieving them.
Mississippi, a state that historically struggled with educational achievement, has made remarkable progress in elementary reading through changes in reading instruction, teacher training, and early intervention. If Mississippi can do it, Michigan can do it too.
If Michigan wants to compete economically and provide a better future for its residents, improving educational achievement must become one of our highest priorities. I would consider it a major accomplishment if, four years from now, Michigan could demonstrate substantial and sustained improvement in elementary reading performance.
3. Finally, Fix the Damn Roads
When Gretchen Whitmer ran for governor in 2018, one of her most memorable campaign promises was to “fix the damn roads.” It was a wonderfully effective campaign slogan because nearly every Michigan motorist understood exactly what she meant. Eight years later, I am still waiting for the results to match the promise.
I recognize that substantial road construction has occurred during Governor Whitmer’s administration. Major highways have been rebuilt, bridges have been repaired, and billions of dollars have been invested in transportation infrastructure. Those accomplishments should be acknowledged. However, I believe too much attention has been directed toward highly visible projects on major highways while many state and local roads remain in poor condition.
I-75 is an example of a highway where motorists can see the results of significant investments. Much of the roadway has improved considerably. Travel beyond the major highways, however, and the picture is quite different. Many of our secondary highways, local roads, and streets continue to suffer from deteriorating pavement, potholes, and repairs that seem to provide only temporary relief.
I live in Petoskey, and each year Leah and I travel by automobile to Gulf Shores, Alabama. That journey takes us through several states and provides an opportunity to compare highway conditions. I have often joked that if Helen Keller were alive today, she would know when she was entering Michigan when she was traveling by car.
I would like Governor Benson and the Legislature to develop a long-term, sustainable road funding and maintenance plan that gives appropriate attention to local roads and secondary highways, not simply the projects that attract the greatest public attention. The plan should include measurable goals, realistic funding sources, transparent reporting, and an emphasis on maintaining roads before they deteriorate to the point where complete reconstruction becomes necessary. I would also like to see the state establish a clear method for evaluating whether the money being spent is producing the improvements taxpayers were promised.
I am not interested in another campaign slogan. I am interested in roads that are safe, properly maintained, and capable of serving Michigan residents and businesses for years to come.
As I wrote on Wednesday about the new Congress in Washington, winning an election is only the beginning. This same applies to Jocelyn Benson and the State Legislature. The real test is how the winners exercise the authority they have been given.
********************************************************************************************************
Quote of the Day
“The best way to find yourself is to lose yourself in the service of others.” — Commonly attributed to Mahatma Gandhi
Public service should be measured by what elected officials accomplish for the people they represent, not by the political offices they obtain or the campaign promises they make.
Orchid of the Day
The University of Michigan’s women’s basketball team for their season opening victory over perennial powerhouse and number two ranked Connecticut. It was the highest ranked team a U of M women’s team has ever defeated. Clearly U of M deserves their number 5 ranking. See the Video of the Day below.
Onion of the Day
Michigan’s longstanding failure to make the governor’s office and Legislature fully accountable under meaningful public-records requirements.
For years, candidates have promised greater transparency while the necessary reforms have remained unfinished. Michigan residents deserve better.
Question of the Day
If you could establish just one priority for Governor-elect Jocelyn Benson and Michigan’s new Legislature, what would it be? Would you choose government transparency, improving our schools, fixing the roads, or something else?
Lyrics of the Day
Today’s lyrics: “Oh where have you been my blue-eyed son.” If you know the answer provide the answer in the comments section below.
Answer to Wednesday’s lyrics: The Times They are a-Changing” by Bob Dylan
Video of the Day: U of M Women’s basketball game highlights of their victor over Connecticut.

